Diary

People who have been reading my blog for some time know how often I process something that’s happening in the political world by analogy to my personal life. I was in a long-term marriage to a narcissist, with my stubbornness to admit defeat being perhaps the single biggest factor in why I stayed married to him as long as I did.  His behaviour brought me to the ground emotionally and financially, and in many respects, I have moved on without being able to fully recover.

I acknowledge that every dysfunctional relationship is a dynamic in which both parties play roles.  In my case, the betrayals were all on his part and took many forms that I won’t itemize here, because my point is not about him. He doesn’t matter anymore. What matters is how I make sense of my own history. I was a loyal and completely faithful wife, who took care of him and our children without receiving the same kind of care in return. It’s really that simple.

How I was complicit is in my lack of ability to set the boundaries that would have stopped him from taking advantage of my qualities of loyalty, fidelity, and loving care. I didn’t fight back when I should have, and I played a role in creating a monster. I know better now. One of the best things about my relationship with my late husband Jim is that I went into it committed to never feeling again the way I felt in my first marriage, and I knew to do that I would have to change. Jim was a good man and he helped me learn that I could express my needs and my feelings without being punished for them, and that my happiness was equally important to his own.

I suppose you could say I retain unprocessed trauma over my first marriage, but the truth is I’m just not that interested anymore. What does continue unprocessed is the connection that his behaviour had to producing two beautiful children who then went on, one in his early 20s and one in his early 40s to end their own lives.  When I look at this from what might be considered an objective perspective, I  see that my firstborn, Adriano, was somewhere on the autism spectrum, which at the time of his death in 1999, at age 22, was associated only with its most severe forms. He could never figure out what others expected of him, and eventually he gave up.  My younger son, Ivan, developed severe bipolar disorder in adulthood, leading to psychotic episodes that would have required heavy medication for the rest of his life. He complained that the drugs destroyed the Ivan he enjoyed being,  replaced by a zombie who could take no joy in life. He hung on for a while, but a debilitating shoulder injury put him over the edge and he too made the gamble that the next world would be better.

I could place the blame on biochemistry and leave it at that, and I do remind myself that faced with those odds, there might have been little that any parents could have done to change the outcome. I could point to history of mental instability in his family, and warning signs I see now that should have made me think twice about marrying him. At 25 there was so much I didn’t know about what would matter in a life partner. Still, I have tried to tread carefully between blaming their father too much and myself too little. 

One thing I do know, though, is that blaming him doesn’t make me feel better. Nor does blaming myself. Still, I think any mother can’t ever put completely to rest any decisions that led to negative consequences for her children. I see more clearly now the role that my stubbornness played in staying married to an increasingly dysfunctional man, when his lack of concern for anyone but himself was hurting my children far more than a divorce ever would. It’s too late to know better now, but forgiving myself for what I didn’t realize at the time has proved elusive.

As often happens with this blog, I take a long time to get to the point. The reason I’m having these thoughts today is an article I read this morning about signs in adults that may show they grew up with a narcissistic parent. I will post the link at the bottom of this entry if you think it might be helpful. Self doubt, hypervigilance, boundary problems, trust issues—the list goes on and on. My response to this article came as quite a revelation. I don’t think either of my children had any of these issues. They could have had them all based only on their father‘s behaviour, but they also had me. 

I provided their normality, their stability, their security in the world. Anyone who has seen pictures of them as children knows that these children were loved. The photo at the top of this post shows a time right after Star Wars was released when I made medals of cardboard covered with aluminum foil that I presented to them for running around the high school track with us. At the bottom, there’s a photo of Adriano (top) and Ivan. It’s me they are looking at, so confident they are my treasured boys.

I protected them in ways I understand better now.  Ivan used to reassure me that I had been a great mom, and in the letter Adriano left he said the same, but I had never been able to accept this because my own narrative about our shared past was so different from theirs. I could have done better in so many ways, and I will always regret that, but given the totality of what was going on in our family, I see now that I did a damn good job of mothering after all. My gift was my love and that will have to be enough.

https://medium.com/the-narcissist-detox/17-signs-you-dealt-with-narcissistic-abuse-as-a-kid-f20a66f6e85f

it’s been more than a decade since I have published anything, and I an delighted to share with you the news that a historical novel I have been working on for several years will be coming out in May 2026 from Sibylline Press. ALOHA WANDERWELL TAKES THE WHEEL tells the fantastic true story of a remarkable teenager who walks away from her boarding school in 1922 to go off on an adventure that will take her around the world behind the wheel of a Model T. Aloha’s story has everything—drama, comedy, adventure, romance, steamy sex, life-threatening events, glamour, heartbreak, joy. Most of all, it’s an inspirational tale of a young woman determined not to cave in to societal expectations, who goes out to live the exciting life she has dreamed of. Do an online search of Aloha Wanderwell, and I think you will see why I just had to tell her story. And while you are here on my website, be sure to take a look at the link here https://laurelcorona.com/laurels-books/aloha-wanderwell/ that will tell you about the book. . The cover, by the way, is a mockup that will be replaced in a few months when I have the actual cover. In the meantime, hereis one of my favourite photos of the one and only Aloha Wanderwell

‘If there is magic on this planet, it is contained in water.” This is the first line of the essay “The Flow of the River,  which opens  Loren Eiseley’s The Immense Journey.   First published in 1959, the book is replete with anachronisms, such as using the word “man” to stand for humanity, and talking about how someday “man” will go into space, but it is to me one of the most exquisite collection of essays ever written. 

This line came to me today as I traveled along the western side of the Canadian Rockies. It started with two of my favourite geological features, glaciers and the ridges called aretes they leave behind.  An arête can be as sharply pointed as an arrowhead, or as long and smooth as an axe blade, formed when glaciers on both sides of a mountain pull the mountain down with them until only a sharp ridge remains.  Often the glacier is long gone, but the shape it left behind is unmistakable, and there are hundred of them in this part of the world . Here is a photo I took from a viewpoint above the town of Revelstoke. It’s not the best image of aretes and glaciers, but it will have to do.

I was driving along a river today and looking up at the jagged mountains when I felt this wave of appreciation for how water shapes landscapes. I thought about soft, white, fluffy snow falling on the mountain peaks, then compressing over time into a river of ice so powerful it can pulverize granite. 

It’s early summer still at this altitude, and yesterday I was trudging through patches of remaining snow on a hike in Mount Revelstoke. It was beautiful to hear the tinkling and gurgling of the little rivulets running out from the snow pack, as they joined a slightly larger stream, which eventually would find its way to a larger one, and then perhaps to a lake, which itself feeds a torrent that will eventually find its way through cascades and falls to the valley below, itself carved by a huge river, like the Thompson, the Fraser, or the Columbia, before finding its way to the sea. 

Nothing new about that.  It’s grade school science.  But what was new for me was realizing that every single thing I was looking at was there because of water, from the tiny wildflowers to the trees, to the shapes of the towering mountains, to the clouds hovering over them.  When astronomers and other scientists talk about potential life elsewhere in the universe, they always start with evidence of water, and here I was, surrounded by an explosion not just of life but of all this magnificent scenery that was there because water makes everything happen. 

 I also found myself thinking about Charles Lyell’s theory of uniformity, which states that the geological forces we see now are the same ones that have shaped the earth from the beginning.  Leave a garden hose on in an area of loose soil and you get a miniature Grand Canyon that mimics exactly the way even the hugest chasms have been formed. Today I stood in front of the second highest waterfall in Canada, fed by an enormous glacier on the plateau above, and feeding the milky river you see at the bottom of the photo. What I was seeing was the same in principle as those trickles of water coming out from under the patches of snow on the trail I had taken the day before. 

None of this is magic, really.  Eiseley and Lyell knew that, and so do I.  But there is something that feels like magic about the ahah moments we all get from time to time, when something we saw only in pieces comes together, when our minds are supple enough to see the connection between what what we are struggling to understand and the messages that are everywhere around us. Sometimes the insight comes from the smallest things, such as when Dylan Thomas speaks of “the round Zion of the water bead,” the tiny, fragile perfection of one drop of water that for him stood for eternity.  For me, the illumination came from imagining water at the opposite extreme. 

Today I was thinking about how some people are dragged down by life, like glaciers pull down mountains, and what remains are only their sharp brittle edges.  And then I see water rushing over rocks glistening with the smoothness they have acquired over time, and I think there are people like those rocks too. I want to be one of those. My heart goes out to people who go through life like walking aretes.  These thoughts passed fleetingly through my mind, of no particular consequence.  Making meaning is always going to be fluid, and the best part is that we can throw out thoughts all day and occasionally something is so right for that moment that it changes us. That’s when we feel maybe there is magic after all.

One of my favourite ways of making meaning is through poetry.  Gerard Manley Hopkins is one of my favourite poets (I quote him often in this blog), and the last lines of his poem “Inversnaid” feel to me like a benediction for all the wonderful experiences I have been having:

What would the world be, once bereft

Of wet and of wildness? Let them be left,

O let them be left, wildness and wet;

Long live the weeds and the wilderness yet.

‘I have the milk of human kindness by the quart in every vein,’ My Fair Lady’s Henry Higgins claims in “I’m an Ordinary Man.”  And what does ordinary mean to him? It’s someone “Who desires nothing more than just an ordinary chance/ To live exactly as he likes and  do precisely what he wants.”

Of course the song highlights the stodgy professor’s cluelessness about what would actually make him happy.  It takes a shabby flower seller in Covent Garden, with none of the qualities Higgins thinks he values, to show him how wrong he has been.

I’ve been thinking about kindness a lot lately, as the reckless and lawless bludgeoning of America goes to greater and greater extremes.  The president and his hatchet man (I don’t even want to type their names) are taking a line from another of England’s memorable protagonists, Hamlet, who tells his mother “I must be cruel only to be kind.” It’s going to hurt, our two contemporary villains tell us, but they assure us we will see in time how their  patriotism has rescued America.

Kindness is so deeply engrained in the human psyche that everyone, except those with certain mental diseases, wants to believe they possess it, even when others question whether they do. Confronted with their cruelty, they say they are misunderstood, their critics lack context, their victims will see in the end the value they gained from suffering.

No.  I don’t think it works that way.  Kindness isn’t complicated. It’s not a long-range strategy hiding behind meanness.  It is just a way of seeing what’s wrong, or what  could be better, and trying to do something about it right now. 

The issue of kindness, and how much of it is natural to us, was highlighted a few days ago on a day trip out of Manaus, Brazil. On the way back, we saw a juvenile sloth come down to the water to drink and then fall into the river. It wasn’t clear whether it intended to get in the water, but once it was in, it started to swim out deeper. We all watched for a while as the boat idled, but at some point, the crew decided the little animal wouldn’t be able to save itself.

It’s simple enough to rescue a drowning sloth.  You just have to put out a pole and as soon as its body touches it, instinct takes over and it curls its arm around the pole. Once inside the boat, the guide carried it around so we all could say hello before they took it back to shore and put it back in a tree. 

Every one of the people on the boat had the same reaction: instant love for this sweet creature. We were gentleness and kindness personified. But how much kindness do we show when the drowning is more abstract? I imagine on that boat we had no such unity of feelings about those who are drowning in debt, addiction, grief, lost love, betrayal. I suspect we would disagree more about what we owe others than what we owe a sloth.  

The Gallup World Poll asked people in 2019 if they thought people would return a lost wallet, and found that people are much too pessimistic about the benevolence of others. The number of wallets returned after being dropped in a street  in one experiment was far higher than  those who were asked to guess about the number had predicted. The respondents didn’t have much faith in human kindness, and that’s sad because apparently they should have had more. Even sadder because it would be so nice to have more.

Interestingly, the Nordic nations, including Denmark, Finland, Norway and Sweden, whose people always rank among the world’s happiest, were among the top places for expected and actual return of lost wallets, the same Gallup World Poll determined. “The wallet data are so convincing because they confirm that people are much happier living where they think people care about each other,” explained John F. Helliwell, an economist at the University of British Columbia and a founding editor of the World Happiness Report.

We have so many opportunities every day to be kind.  We like ourselves more when we are, and I don’t know why that isn’t enough to make us try to be phenomenally better people.  Or maybe just a little better. Happiness doesn’t lie in the shallow egocentrism of Henry Higgins.  I don’t want to be ordinary.  I want to be better than that.  I want other people to live as they like and do what they want too, not just me. I will always return a lost wallet, and maybe I can do more to return others’ lost confidence, lost hope, lost feelings of being cared about and loved.  There’s not much in this awful time I feel I can do anything about, but there’s that old saying about lighting a candle rather than cursing the darkness. I’m going to give it a try.

Yesterday I went on a tour out of the Chilean port of Puerto Montt to go to several villages on Lake Llanquihue, the second largest lake in the country.  Its backdrop is Osorno, one of those perfect cone volcanos that make Chile so unique in our beautiful world. 

I’ll spare you all the little signs that this was not a day that would go exactly as planned, but suffice it to say that my travel companion Megan and I were laughing most of the way through the first stop in Frutillar about how just buying a take-out empanada became a project that took the first half hour of our one-hour stop, and that was not the first glitch. 

Then the fun really began when our bus broke down. We were stranded on a side street of one of those towns you would barely glance at passing through. We were told our new bus would be there in a half an hour, but anyone who’s travelled much knows that in many countries people are so unwilling to disappoint that they give pleasant assurances that have no foundation in fact. Since the nearest town big enough to have a bus available to send was an hour away, I knew this was one of these times.

About half of us piled off the bus and hung around for a few minutes while the rest stayed on board. Then after arranging a time, we should all be back, a group of us set off to explore and maybe, if we were lucky, find someplace to have a cup of coffee. Honestly, what ensued in the hour and change we spent together before the new bus arrived will probably go down as one of the highlights of this entire trip around South America. 

Objectively speaking, I suppose you could say we didn’t find much—not even a cup of coffee—but subjectively the time was filled with discoveries I loved about typical small-town life in Chile. We discovered that pretty much every shop leaves their “abierto” sign lit up all the time whether they are open or not. We found one shop after another so small our group of eight couldn’t fit in all at once. We saw one dog so bored he didn’t look up when we passed, and another who snarled and lunged at us against his fence in the spirit of the proverbial junkyard dog.  We found a little odds-and-ends store that had a pile of embroidered pillow covers for $2.50 apiece and a few of us bought some as souvenirs (from India, I suppose) of our great day. Someone found a bakery and bought a bag of eight pieces of bread for what seemed like pennies, and we all shared. Throughout, we were all laughing at how anyone who encountered us must have been perplexed as to why a group of gringos suddenly descended on them in their little corner of the world. 

When we got back to the bus we, of course, heard another half hour had been added on to our rescue time. We continued to hang out on the street, a few of us spending some time recasting Gilligan’s Island with the people on board the bus. They all agreed that obviously I was the professor. We even had a redhead to be Ginger. There was an air show going on at a nearby base, with flyovers we all agreed it was cool we hadn’t missed.

I got back on the bus at some point and felt blasted almost immediately with an energy that was radically different. Those who had sat on the stuffy bus all that time were in a state. Grim faces said it all. A few were demanding to go straight back and skip the rest of the tour. I am trying very hard not to judge people, so I suppose there were some who really did count on being back on time.  It was noon by then, and I know some people have medical issues around missed meals and dosages that must be taken, but still it was hard not to contrast the pleasure in the moment happening outside and available to anyone who wanted it. 

I am indeed rambling towards a point here.  It’s hard to stay positive in these bleak times, but it’s always a choice, whether facing a broken down bus or a breaking down country. I suppose the simplest takeaway is the old bromide that we can at least control our reactions in situations we can’t control, but to me the better, and more hopeful lesson was about how optimism and resilience win in the end.

Laughter matters. Kidding around is important. We need to treat these as precious gifts we give to ourselves and others.  The world is huge, but at any given moment we are only on a speck of it and it is up to us to make that speck a good one.

I started this blog in September 2008 to coincide with the publication of my first two books, The Four Seasons and Until Our Last Breath. It evolved fairly quickly from primarily promoting my work as an author, to sharing my experiences and ideas as a person. Now 440 posts later, I think of it mostly as a means to bring my thoughts into focus, and to share what I think might be of value to others as we all find our way through the complicated puzzle of our lives. 

I haven’t posted much for the last few months because I, like so many, have felt the bucket of cold water we call the news poured over my head several times a day. To say that the worsening onslaught since the inauguration makes it difficult to put together coherent thoughts about the meaning of life  is an understatement so huge it’s hard not to laugh, however bitterly. I  am so busy just trying to manage my thoughts and protect my spirit that I have little room for anything more. 

Those of you who have known me, or followed this blog for a few years, know that I sometimes look  back at my first marriage to a narcissist for insights about what is happening in the present. Since the rise of the current occupant of the White House, I have seen so many parallels between the way my ex-husband treated me and our children, and the way the current president treats everyone. 

To go deeply into this would take volumes and serve no purpose except to upset me, so I am going to stick with one point:  narcissists don’t see other people as real.   Malignant narcissists might enjoy causing pain and distress, but the garden variety like my ex simply don’t take into consideration the flesh-and-blood nature of other people. Our feelings are irrelevant, our needs trivial, our well being inconsequential.

It really is that simple, but with the person America elected to lead it, this plays out on an unimaginable scale. He slashes away at will, or permits others to do it, without the slightest awareness that people care about themselves. They care about their lives, their children, their livelihoods, their future. Healthier people find his and his cronies’ behaviour incomprehensible because how in the world could anyone be so clueless? Surely this must stop somewhere! Well, narcissists are that clueless, and it won’t. We are left now to predict future disasters by asking ourselves, “what would someone who doesn’t see other people as real do in this situation?”

 In the past few days, a handful of acolytes are attempting to destroy the capacity of the government to pay debts because people who rely on government entitlements and services aren’t real. Entire agencies are shut down and people are fired or furloughed because neither they nor the people they serve actually have lives. Today’s great idea is to move two million of the not-real out of Gaza so he can fashion it into a new Riviera for that special group of not-reals from whom he can extract money. What does it matter where the Gazans go? What does it matter what they think and want?

And what will it be tomorrow, and the next day?  Whose lives and human dignity will be inconsequential next?  He may be erratic and perhaps a bit mad, but our being unreal to him is one thing we can count on. 

On January 20, I set sail from Fort Lauderdale on what is undoubtedly the biggest single adventure in my twelve years of cruise lecturing. I am traveling all the way around South America and will arrive back in Fort Lauderdale on April 1, for a total of 72 days aboard, during which I will give 28 different talks—like a semester at sea for retirees!  

My assignment is as a destination speaker, which means I am responsible for informing guests about all the places we will visit, but what excites me more is the opportunity to go beyond that and pull in other things I have learned from my decades as a professor of humanities, and wherever else my lifelong curiosity has taken me. It is so fun for me to have a built-in and eager audience for things I love to talk about.

I am a natural early riser—for me 9 to 5 is more like a sleep schedule than a work day.  One of my favourite things to do on the ship is get up before dawn and head for the lounge on the bow of the ship, get coffee from the machine and watch the sky lighten and another day begin. My perch is what you see in the photo above.   As the ship glides through the darkness, I feel most akin with the people below me on the bridge, who have guided us through the night and whose expertise keeps us safe and on course. 

I poke around on my iPad, looking into what my friends are up to, dabbling carefully and cautiously into the news, playing a few word games, and seeing what else there is to know about the world.  Around 6:30 or so, a few other people start coming through, most just to get coffee and stagger back to their suites, but a few to settle in as I have. 

The spell is broken with the first human voices—mostly people doing business on the other side of the world. The ship is not solely mine anymore, and I start to think about my day.  Today at 10 I will speak about Alexander von Humboldt and his time in South America, one of my all time favourite talks.  After that I will change into shorts and flip flops and check out what’s going on around the ship, followed by lunch outside.  Then, who knows?  

When I come back, the suite attendant will have made up the bed, and honestly, forget the food, forget the ports! Seeing those brilliant white million-thread-count sheets, so crisp and tight on the bed, is one of the biggest thrills in cruising for me.  It tells me I am being taken care of in the loveliest of ways, and I am free to relax and enjoy my time as I wish.

Is this my life? I shake my head every day in wonder. True, I work very, very hard to be ready (five months of work for this assignment), and onboard, I put a lot of effort into being worthy of the privilege, but if it were possible to melt into a puddle of gratitude, I would have done it long ago.

I love living in Victoria, and when I am away I always look forward to coming back home. That’s why I have always been surprised by how returns bring with them a touch of depression. 

I have attributed this to many things, most obviously jet lag, which makes me so unlike myself for a few days.  Occasionally on leaving a ship where the crew have made it feel like a second home, I feel a bit bereft. And then there’s the need to figure out how to manage the complications of a life where I am not being taken care of hand and foot, day and night. It’s amazing how quickly I can forget where a light switch is, or where I keep the coffee filters. And now, all the things that had to wait until I got home suddenly need to be scheduled and done. 

This time, add to all that the horrific results of the election, the vestiges of a touch of food poisoning, and the brief loss of my luggage, to make this return additionally besieging. But this morning, around 4am, my typical wake up time during jet lag recovery after bedtime at 8, I put my finger on why, even with easier returns than this one, I feel so out of sorts. 

I have written here many times in the past about my decision to uproot my life and move to Canada in 2020. For any readers who didn’t know me then, in order to do this, I sold my condo, got rid of all my furniture and any possessions that wouldn’t fit in my car and drove to Victoria, sight unseen and knowing no one, trusting it would work out. I now live in a furnished heritage rental, with the world’s best owners living upstairs. I own nothing now except my clothes, jewelry (lots of earrings!) and my car. I don’t own a lamp or a throw pillow. Nada.  Zip.  To my way of seeing it, this is working out very well indeed!

But still, there is something about returning home to an environment filled with the identity of a whole life—from the knickknacks, to the art, even to the favourite dishes, that I no longer get to experience. There’s a moment where you open the door coming home and say “this is my real life.”  I don’t feel that way in part because my real life is also on ships half the year, but largely because any place I live now and for the rest of my life will never really be mine in the same way it was before I flew the coop in my car. 

 I’ve written in the past about nesters and perchers—those who need a comfy place to call home, and those who are fine wherever they are.  I am a percher to the core, but there are those moments when I remember how good it felt to  come home and see everything waiting for me, reminding me of the sum of my life. I don’t have that anymore, and I guess somewhere deep in the gut, it affects me. 

This life isn’t for everyone. For a small percentage of my head and heart, it isn’t for me either for a day or two, while I adjust to the wonderful, unencumbered reality I have made for myself. I made my choice, and I must be at home wherever I am. That soft nest to fall into must be inside me, where my fundamental identity and my most important memories live. The rest is just stuff. I’ve got the right outerwear and good winter shoes, money in the bank, and friends who are there to welcome me home to my life in Victoria, where I already feel much more settled just by writing this. 

These are the words on the tombstone of Nikos Kazantzakis, author of Zorba the Greek and many other works of fiction, poetry, and philosophy. When I was in college, I inhaled every word he wrote and even now, more than half a century later, I still remember his challenge to take on the heavy intellectual and spiritual work required to have a life of true joy and deep meaning. 

The photo below is of me laying flowers on his grave when Jim and I were there in 2008. It was the number one thing I wanted to do when I first visited Heraklion, Crete, where he is buried.  The one at the end of the post is of the epigraph on the other side of his tombstone, carved as he wrote it by hand.

I can’t say I’ve always lived up to the challenge of his words.  I haven’t always tried that hard to do so. But I still think that those few words are the best guidance I ever received. 

Kazantzakis wasn’t arguing against optimism or faith in the future, only against being wrapped up in expectations of favorable outcomes.  Likewise I think what he meant by fearing nothing isn’t that he shrugged off real threats, but that he wasn’t cluttering his mind with imagined unfavorable outcomes.

It shouldn’t come as a surprise that Kazantzakis was a great admirer of the Buddha, for their philosophies are both grounded in the idea that attachment is the source of suffering. We hope to get what we want and we fear we will get what we don’t want.  We want to keep what we like and get rid of what we dislike. Both are burdens, and feeling burdened is the antithesis of feeling free.

So why am I thinking about this now?  Like pretty much everyone, I am losing  my sense of well being over this election. I am emotionally exhausted with both hope and fear. 

Kazantzakis’ book The Saviors of God was at one point like the Bible for me, and one line has stuck in my memory all these years: “We shine like humble pebbles as long as they remain immersed in the sea.”  I’m sure you have picked up a wet pebble and admired the beauty of its colors, only to pull it later from your pocket to find it grey and dull. Maybe humans are like that too. Forces we cannot control bring out the best in us, revealing our true colors only when we are most caught up in them. 

This is a good time to remember that. The only answer to this terrible political situation is to accept that we are always immersed in the sum totality of what simply is—good or bad, favorable or unfavorable, scary or comforting. Our hopes and fears are tiny and ultimately meaningless battles with the future. Whatever happens, our life’s purpose is to continue to shine. 

Any writer is a word nerd, and I plead guilty. Finding the perfect word or making up a new one lifts my spirits in a way unlike anything else. Another category of word fun is dictionary digging—playing around with a common word that has many meanings, preferably contradictory. 

The other day I was reading an article explaining the world views of Plato and Aristotle. The author, one of my favourite columnists, Arthur Brooks, explained that the fundamental difference between the two philosophers was Plato’s view of reality as a fixed entity and Aristotle’s view that reality is characterized by change. Applying that to people, Brooks’ point was that to Plato, there is a fixed core that defines us, and to Aristotle every individual is perpetually in a state of becoming.  

My guess is that it’s a bit of both. There are ways in which I don’t think I have changed at all.  My desire for social justice, my optimism, my belief that most people are decent and trustworthy are things I have carried throughout my life. And yet, I never have the sense that I have finished evolving into the whole person I am meant to be.  The thing I like most about my life is that I am still growing. 

The Brooks article got me thinking about the word “becoming.” Maybe it sounds a little old-fashioned now, but I grew up hearing it used for appearances and actions. “That dress is very becoming,” someone might say, or the opposite, “that behaviour is not very becoming.” What in the world is an article of clothing or an infraction of manners in the process of becoming?  How can that word possibly apply?

Online Cambridge and Webster say “becoming” is an adjective that means attractive and suitable, and that is pretty much the end of the discussion. Nothing of philosophy at all in the word. I looked up the verb “become,” and I found a much longer and interesting history. Old English “becuman” meant “to come (to), approach, arrive, enter, meet with, fall in with; happen, befall; befit.”

Okay, I get the connection with befitting, but the rest of the meanings seem almost comical. By this standard, saying an outfit is becoming is rather like saying “that dress shows you are making progress towards a sense of style.”  Or perhaps, in this throwaway society one could argue that the only thing an article of clothing is becoming is landfill.  Then again, to say slurping soup is unbecoming does get at the idea that such behaviour is heading in the wrong direction.

Ah, vocabulary.  The stuff of endless weirdness. Time to give up on the dictionary and go back to Aristotle and Plato. Maybe one part of a satisfying life is to have a clear sense of what about ourselves we never want to change—our core identity, as shown in how we behave and what we believe. Maybe the other part of that satisfying life is feeling that we continue on an exciting trajectory of growth and change. Josh Groban  said it best in “Let Me Fall”

Someone I am is waiting for courage

The one I want, the one I will become will catch me

What a great image.  We jump and the person we become in jumping is the one who catches us. There’s a Laurel waiting for me whom I haven’t met yet.  It may not be an easy path to her. There are occasions to rise to, choices to make. The Platonic side keeps me grounded, but the Aristotelian side reminds me that only if I jump can I find my wings.